Should The Government Protect Us From Ourselves?
Here’s a question I’ve been pondering lately:
Should the government protect us from ourselves?
I actually asked this very question on Twitter, and the responses were quite mixed. I sort of expected a clear-cut winner, but that was not the case.
If the government were to protect us from ourselves, it would mean that society could not undermine it’s own country, even if it wanted to. But what does this imply? This would imply that the government no longer represents its people’s wishes. That seems bad to me.
On the flip side, if the government did not go against the common word, the people would end up destroying the nation (again, assuming that was society’s intent). We already know that majority rule is not always ideal, and so it would be wrong to allow the majority to destroy a nation against the will of the minority. Maybe you disagree with me here, but that’s how I see it.
This is a fundamental question I think, because your viewpoint here determines what you want and do not want the government to be able to do. Those who strongly believe in the will of the people would argue that the government has no choice but to listen to the people’s demands, even if that demand is the destruction of the government/nation. Those who believe that people sometimes do not know what is best would argue that the government has the right to tell them what is right and what is wrong. I… am torn.
To me it seems to be a case-by-case basis matter. Sometimes I do want popular vote to matter, and other times I want the government to know what is best, especially since the people can never know all the facts or even pretend to. But where do we draw the line? How do we figure out what the government should determine and what the people should determine? At what point should the government stop even indirectly representing the majority? Should the government ever stop representing the majority of its people at all?
Comments would be greatly appreciated.
Oh, if you’d like to have my blog’s posts delivered to you via email, that is now available at the top of the sidebar.


